155 Amsterdam Ave /corner of 67th street, New York, NY 10023 212-874-2000
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

  • a slice of octopus on a plate
    Slide 1 of 2
  • a close up of a sandwich on a plate
    Slide 2 of 2

    • APPETIZERS

    • TRIO DE TAQUITOS

      Tuna, lobster & shrimp, crispy shell, chipotle remoulade

      $16

    • BAKED QUAHOGS CLAMS

      Chorizo, garlic, parsley, peppers, bread crumbs, cotija

      $13

    SOUPS

    Bowl $11

    • NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER

    • LOBSTER BISQUE

    SALADS

    • KALE CAESAR SEAFOOD

      Kale, cherry tomatoes, avocado, caesar dressing, crispy tortillas

      $13

      With Seafood (shrimp, calamari, octopus) $16

    RAW BAR

    • 1/2 DOZEN LITTLE NECK CLAMS

      $16

    • 1/2 DOZEN WEST COAST OYSTERS

      $21

    • 1/2 DOZEN EAST COAST OYSTERS

      $18

    SANDWICHES

    Served with coleslaw, pickles, toasted brioche bun, and house-made fries

    • PO BOY

      Fried oysters, calamari, shrimp, chipotle remoulade, lettuce, tomato

      $18

    GINTONERIA

    • THE ANCHOR

      Gin, muddled raspberry, lime juice, Fever-Tree Mediterranean tonic water

      $12

    • MAR Y SOL

      Oxley Gin, muddled blackberry and cucumber, lime juice, Fever-Tree tonic water

      $12

    • HIGH TIDE

      Gin, pineapple puree, lemon juice, Campari, Fever-Tree Sparkling Lemon tonic water

      $12

    FRIED SHACK BUCKETS

    House-made Fries & Aji Verde Aioli

    • CHOICE OF:

      Calamari or Shrimp

      $18

    • JALEA

      Peruvian fried shrimp, fish, calamari, red onion salsa Criolla, crispy yucca, aji verde aioli

      $22

    LOBSTERS

    • WHOLE LOBSTER

      1 1/4 Pounder Market Price

      STEAMED

      GRILLED

      ANGRY: Cut in pieces and sautéed with our house-made spicy Shack tomato hot sauce and corn

    • LOBSTER FISH SHACK

      1 1/4 pound steamed lobster, corn, coleslaw

      $35

    • LOBSTER TACOS

      3 soft corn tortillas with spicy mayo and avocado

      $19

    • LOBSTER ROLL

      Lobster salad, lemon aioli, dill, chives, pickled Fresno chiles with side of fries

      $26

    • BAKED STUFFED LOBSTER

      1 1/4 lobster, stuffed with shrimp, scallops, lobster, and chimichurri

      $42

    FROM THE FISH MARKET

    With your choice of sauce and one side

    • SIMPLY GRILLED

      OCTOPUS $28

      with your choice of side

    • GRILLED OR FRIED WHOLE FISH

      BRANZINO $35

      RED SNAPPER $35

      served with your choice of side

    • SELECT YOUR SAUCE

      LEMON & OLIVE OIL

      ANGRY-EL SHACK TOMATO

    • SIDES

      HOUSE-MADE FRENCH FRIES $7

      LEMON POTATOES $8

      COLE SLAW $7

      STEAMED CORN OR MEXICAN STYLE $6

      MAC & CHEESE $8

      MAC & CHEESE WITH LOBSTER $20

      SAUTÉED SPICY KALE $7

    EL SURF & TURF

    • NY PRIME STRIP FRITES

      Grilled dry-aged NY strip and half lobster, house-made fries, chimichurri

      $45

    Appetizers

    • Trio de Taquitos

      Tuna, lobster & shrimp, crispy shell, chipotle remoulade

      $16

    • Baked Quahogs Clams

      Chorizo, garlic, parsley, peppers, bread crumbs, cotija

      $13

    • Steamed Mussels

      Choice of:
      White Wine & Herbs
      Angry – tomato, house-made El Shack hot sauce

      $18

    Fried Shack Buckets

    House-made Fries & Aji Verde Aioli

    • CHOICE OF:

      $18

      Calamari

      Clams

      Shrimp

      Oysters

    • Jalea

      Peruvian fried shrimp, fish, calamari, red onion salsa Criolla, crispy yucca, aji verde aioli

      $22

    • Fish & Chips

      Lightly battered cod, chili vinegar

      $22

    Soups & Salads


    Soups

    Bowl $11

    • New England Clam Chowder

    • Lobster Bisque

    • Chupe

      Peruvian soup, shrimp, potato, choclo, carrots, aji panca, queso fresco

    Salads

    • Greek

      Romaine, cucumber, tomato, feta cheese, dill, olives, olive oil, and lemon

      $13

    • Kale Caesar Seafood

      Kale, shrimp, calamari, octopus, cherry tomatoes, avocado, caesar dressing, crispy tortillas

      $16

    Lobster

    Whole Lobster

    1 1/4 - 2 - 3 Pounders Market Price

    • Choice Of

    • Steamed

    • Grilled

    • Angry

      Cut in pieces and sautéed with our house-made spicy Shack tomato hot sauce and corn

    Lobster Dishes

    • Lobster Fish Shack

      1 1/4 pound steamed lobster, corn, potatoes, coleslaw

      $35

    • Lobster tacos

      3 soft corn tortillas with spicy mayo and avocado

      $19

    • Lobster Roll

      Lobster salad, lemon aioli, dill, chives, pickled Fresno chiles

      $22

    • Lobster Waffle

      Corn butter, chili maple syrup

      $19

    • Baked Stuffed Lobster

      1 1/4 lobster, stuffed with shrimp, scallops, lobster, and chimichurri

      $37

    Raw Bar

    • West Coast Oysters

      Market price

    • East Coast Oysters

      Market price

    • Jumbo Cocktail Shrimp

      $5 per piece

    • Half Lobster Cocktail

      $15

    • 1/2 Dozen Little Neck Clams

      $16

    • Tuna Causa

      Mashed pumpkin, aji amarillo, spicy tuna tartar

      $17

    • El Pequeño Platter

      6 oysters, 6 clams, tuna causa

      $38

    • El Grande Platter

      12 oysters, 6 clams, tuna causa, 3 jumbo shrimp, 1/2 lobster

      $80

    Fish Market

    With your choice of sauce and side

    Grilled or Fried Whole Fish

    Market price

    • Branzino

    • Black Sea Bass

    • Red Snapper

    Sides

    Choose one side

    • House-Made French Fries

      $7

    • Onion Rings

      $7

    • Lemon Potatoes

      $8

    • Cole Slaw

      $7

    • Steamed Corn or Mexican Style

      $6

    • Sautéed Spicy Kale

      $7

    • Steamed or Sautéed Seasonal Veggies

      $8

    • Mac & Cheese

      $8

      Add lobster $12

    Simply Grilled

    • Salmon Steak

      $22

    • Tuna

      $27

    • Octopus

      $22

    • Four Jumbo Shrimp

      Head-on

      $26

    • Scallops

      $26

    Select Your Sauce

    • Lemon & Olive Oil

    • Angry-El Shack Tomato

    • Hot Sauce

    • Chimichurri

    • Yuzu-Soy

    Sandwiches

    Served with coleslaw, pickles, toasted brioche bun, and homemade fries 

    • El Fish

      Crispy cod fish, chipotle remoulade, chili vinegar, lettuce, tomato

      $16

    • Po Boy

      Fried oysters, calamari, shrimp, chipotle remoulade, lettuce, tomato

      $18

    • Crab Roll

      Crab salad, lemon aioli, dill, chives, pickled Fresno chiles

      $18

    • Beef Burger

      Pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, Shack aioli

      $16

    Surf & Turf

    • NY Prime Strip Frites

      Grilled dry-aged NY strip, house-made fries, chimichurri, and half lobster

      $45

    Drinks 

    Gintoneria

    • The Anchor

      Gin, muddled raspberry, lime juice, Fever-Tree Mediterranean tonic water

      $12

    • Mar y Sol

      Oxley Gin, muddled blackberry and cucumber, lime juice, Fever-Tree tonic water

      $12

    • The Stormy

      Apple infused Gin, fresh ginger, Fever-Tree ginger beer

      $12

    • High Tide

      Gin, pineapple puree, lemon juice, Campari, Fever-Tree Sparkling Lemon tonic water

      $12

    • El Costeño

      Gin, muddled grapefruit, agave, Fever-Tree Elderflower tonic water, flamed thyme garnish

      $12

    Cocktails

    • Skinny Bourbon

      Bourbon, mint, fresh lemon juice, Aperol

      $13

    • El Pescador

      Vodka, muddled peach, lime juice, Fever-Tree ginger beer

      $12

    • Frozen Raspados

      Choice: Choice of Mango, Strawberry, Lime, Tamarind

      $12

    • Mezcalita de Piña

      Mezcal, grilled pineapple, jalapeño, cilantro, fresh lime juice

      $13

    • Sangria

      Red or white wine, orange liqueur, apples, grapes, oranges, and peaches

      $12

    • Daiquiri

      Rum, fresh lime juice, agave

      $12

    Beers

    $6
    Montauk Craft Beer

    • Wave Chaser IPA

    • Pumpkin Ale

    • Montauk, NY

    Sunday

    • Brooklyn, NY

    Narragansett Fresh Catch

    • Rhode Island

    Estrella Galicia

    • Spain

    New Belgium

    • Voodoo Ranger IPA

    • Fort Collins, CO

    Lagunitas

    • IPA

    • California

    Weihenstephaner

    • Germany

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!